In a PC World article today it’s mentioned that Vista still has major incompatibility problems nine months after release. Brothers’ multi-function printers don’t work correctly, it’s not possible to fax over the Internet, Photoshop CS2 won’t work – and so on. I don’t care particularly since I don’t plan on upgrading to Vista for a year anyway, but it’s still interesting information. But the most interesting thing wasn’t the article itself, but the comments it received on a Swedish magazine site which summarized the PC World article. The usual bitching and moaning occurred: “Vista is slow” (I bet it is, so don’t use it), “Use Linux instead” (no thanks), “XP is better” (agreed, actually), “Vista is still in beta” (no it’s not; it’s just badly implemented) and on and on and on.
Then, all of the sudden, comes an interesting exchange of comments:
“Apple changes architecture with less problems than MS changes Word format!”
“There’s a difference between changing architecture for 4% of the users compared to changing something for 95%. If you’re using Apple you’re stuck with Macintosh – it’s a simple task to write drivers for such a narrow range of hardware.”
“[Inane comment snippet snipped] Well, I’d rather be locked in by Apple than shut out by Microsoft.”
I found that last comment very interesting because it reflects my own view about Microsoft and Linux: I’d rather be locked in with this proprietary OS and have all the functionality and programs I need, compared to use Linux. In theory I like Linux – Open Source is appealing, Ubuntu and that ilk looks pretty nifty, I love the customizability, and so on. But for my uses Windows XP beats all and any Linux distribution hands down, because I feel shut out from Linux.
All metaphors and similes break down eventually if you examine the objects in question close enough, and so does my simile between the Apple/MS and MS/Linux situation. I’m generalizing horribly, but one could view things this way:
Mac: Small user base, small set of proprietary programs, low customizability.
Windows: Large user base, large set of proprietary programs, low customizability.
Linux: Small user base, large set of open programs, great customizability.
I can hear the outrage of Linux/Mac users. “What about stability, what about look and feel, what about this and that!” All good points, I’m sure, but since I’m trying to come to a conclusion instead of complicating things up even further I’ll disregard all of those things.
Now, looking at my small summary of the OSs, what can we observe?
First, that Mac users might have a stronger feeling of community compared to Windows users due to the smaller set of users and programs. This would be an excellent reason to feel shut out by Windows. But – to show where my simile above crashes and burns horribly – there really is no similar case between Windows and Linux. And to confuse things even further, I like Mac OS X but I feel shut out by that as well! If I extrapolate even further from these facts I eventually come to this little list:
- Mac users feel alienated from Windows.
- Windows users feel alienated from Linux.
- Windows users feel alienated from Mac.
- Mac users probably feel alienated from Linux too.
- Just as Linux users probably feel alienated from Windows and Mac.
What’s the conclusion, then? That OS debates eventually break down into territorial pissings and a case of liking what you’re used to – especially the programs you’re familiar with – so it’s bloody ridiculous to even try to be objective.
“Hey, what about all the examples of people who’ve abandoned Windows for Linux or Mac?”
If they were used to Windows and knew how to use it properly there wouldn’t be a cause for them to switch.
“But I knew this guy who had used Windows for ten years and then fell in love with Linux! Doesn’t that invalidate your comment above?”
I doubt that he used Windows properly then – I’m betting that he forced himself to use tools he didn’t like.
“Programs are irrelevant! There are always applications with equal functionality on all platforms, so anyone can cross over to a new OS without any problems.”
Use your GIMP if you like it. I don’t, though!
So there.